Audit a DBQ or nexus letter before you submit it.
Commander Check
Got a DBQ or nexus letter from somewhere else? Smart move getting private evidence. Before you submit, run it through Commander Check — we'll flag anything the VA commonly uses to reject or discount private medical opinions. Takes 2 minutes.
Commander Check
Never stored- What VA discountsThe completeness and compliance issues the VA commonly uses to reject, discount, or mark a private medical opinion insufficient.
- A tiered reportCritical, warning and passing — each with why it matters and how to fix it, so you know what to take back to the provider.
- Parsed in your browserThe PDF is read on your device. Only its text is checked, and your document is never stored.
What you get back
The report, finding by finding.
This is Commander Check's real report on a sample letter — an invented veteran and a deliberately thin letter, run through the same audit your upload gets.
It names the provider details a rater uses to verify the opinion, the evidentiary standard it has to state, and the rationale it has to show — and says plainly what already passes.
A completeness and compliance audit only — not a medical opinion, and never a prediction of what VA decides.
Commander Check results
Your document has 1 critical issue, 7 warnings, and 6 passing checks.
🔴 Critical(1)
VA will likely reject or mark insufficient. Must fix before submitting.
NPI number missing
No National Provider Identifier was found.
Why it matters: Raters use the NPI to verify the opinion came from a credentialed provider.
How to fix: Add the provider's 10-digit NPI.
🟡 Warning(7)
Weakens the claim. Should fix if possible.
State license number not found
No state license number was detected. Many providers include only their NPI on nexus letters, which is acceptable.
Why it matters: Including your state license strengthens the credential block and removes any ambiguity about licensure.
How to fix: Ask your provider to add their state license number and state to the signature block if not already present.
Benefit-of-the-doubt not cited
No reference to the benefit-of-the-doubt rule was found.
Why it matters: Citing 38 U.S.C. § 5107(b) / 38 C.F.R. § 3.102 reminds the rater of the standard favoring the veteran.
How to fix: Reference the benefit-of-the-doubt doctrine (38 U.S.C. § 5107(b)).
No 38 C.F.R. citation
No 38 C.F.R. regulatory citation was found.
Why it matters: Grounding the opinion in the governing regulation strengthens it.
How to fix: Cite the controlling regulation (e.g. § 3.303 direct, § 3.310 secondary).
Medical rationale / mechanism not explained
No pathophysiological mechanism or causal rationale was found.
Why it matters: An opinion that asserts a link without explaining the mechanism is easy to discount.
How to fix: Explain the specific physiological mechanism connecting the condition to service.
No peer-reviewed citations
No medical literature citations were found.
Why it matters: Supporting literature strengthens the medical rationale.
How to fix: Cite relevant peer-reviewed literature (with PMID or DOI).
In-service event not tied to the condition
No specific in-service event tied to the condition was found.
Why it matters: The nexus must connect the condition to a specific in-service event or exposure.
How to fix: Reference the specific in-service event, injury, or exposure the condition stems from.
Letter is short (likely insufficient)
The letter is 109 words — under the ~500-word depth a weight-bearing nexus opinion usually needs.
Why it matters: Short nexus letters often lack the specific rationale the VA needs and are easy to discount.
How to fix: Expand the opinion with condition-specific clinical detail, mechanism, and evidence.
🟢 Passing(6)
Meets the standard.
Provider identified
A provider name or credential was detected.
Why it matters: The rater must be able to identify and weight the opining provider.
Provider credentials present
A clinical credential (MD/DO/NP/PA/…) was detected.
Why it matters: Credentials establish the provider is competent to render the opinion.
Nexus standard language present
Standard nexus language (e.g. 'at least as likely as not') was detected.
Why it matters: This is the exact evidentiary standard the rater evaluates a nexus against.
Veteran identified
The letter identifies the veteran.
Why it matters: The opinion must be tied to the specific veteran and claim.
Condition named
A specific claimed condition is named.
Why it matters: The opinion must name the condition it connects to service.
Date present
A date was detected on the letter.
Why it matters: A dated opinion anchors the evidence in the claim timeline.
Found issues the VA could use against you?
Want us to generate a replacement that passes all of these checks? VACC drafts a DBQ or nexus document built to the evidentiary standard raters evaluate against — free for veterans.
Start with VACCCommander Check is a completeness and compliance audit — not a medical opinion and not a replacement for your document. It flags issues the VA commonly uses to discount private evidence; it does not guarantee any claim outcome. Have a licensed provider review any clinical content.
No letter yet?
Build one from your own records
Commander drafts the medical opinion from your records and your own words, for your clinician to review — and, if they agree, sign.