Under 38 CFR § 3.105(a), a final VA decision is accepted as correct unless it contains clear and unmistakable error (CUE): an error of fact or law that, on the record and the law as they stood when the decision was made, undebatably changed the outcome. If VA finds CUE, it reverses or amends the old decision, and the corrected decision takes effect as if it had been made on the original date, which can mean years of back pay.
There is no deadline to ask, and it can reach decisions from decades ago. That retroactive power is exactly why the standard is so demanding. A CUE is not a disagreement, a re-weighing of the evidence, or a second opinion. It is a claim that the original decision was undebatably wrong on the record that existed at the time.
What § 3.105(a) says, paragraph by paragraph
Section 3.105(a)(1) sets the rule and then breaks it into seven parts. In plain words:
| Paragraph | What it says |
|---|---|
| (a)(1) | Final decisions are accepted as correct on the evidence and law that existed at the time, unless there was CUE. Once a decision is final, you can ask for CUE review at any time, and VA can start one itself. |
| (a)(1)(i) Definition | CUE is a very specific and rare kind of error, of fact or of law, that compels the conclusion, to which reasonable minds could not differ, that the result would have been manifestly different but for the error. If it is not absolutely clear that a different result would have followed, it is not CUE. |
| (a)(1)(ii) Effective date | A decision revised for CUE has the same effect as if the corrected decision had been made on the date of the original one. |
| (a)(1)(iii) Record reviewed | Review is limited to the evidence and law that existed when the decision was made. VA's duty to assist (§ 3.159) does not apply to a CUE request. |
| (a)(1)(iv) Change in interpretation | A later change in how a statute or regulation is interpreted is not CUE. |
| (a)(1)(v) Limitation | A regional office decision on an issue that the Board or a court later decided on appeal can't be revised under this paragraph. |
| (a)(1)(vi) Examples | Points to 38 CFR 20.1403(d) for examples of what is not CUE. |
| (a)(1)(vii) Filing requirements | The request must be in writing and signed; name the claimant and give the VA file number and the date of the decision; identify each issue; and state the specific error, its factual or legal basis, and why the result would have been manifestly different. General, non-specific allegations are not enough. |
| (a)(2) | Before a claim is finally decided, earlier binding decisions are accepted unless they are "clearly erroneous," a separate standard for decisions that are not yet final. |
The rest of § 3.105, subsection by subsection
Veterans usually meet this regulation in one of two moments: trying to reopen an old decision, or holding a letter that says the VA intends to take something away. Both live here. Section 3.105 is titled Revision of decisions, and it runs from (a) through (j).
| § | Official heading | What it governs |
|---|---|---|
| (a) | Error in final decisions | The CUE rule. A final decision is accepted as correct on the record and law that existed at the time — unless there was clear and unmistakable error. |
| (b) | Difference of opinion | Revision on the basis of a later difference of opinion. A separate track from the CUE standard in (a). |
| (c) | Character of discharge | Decisions about whether the character of your discharge bars benefits. |
| (d) | Severance of service connection | The VA taking away service connection it previously granted. |
| (e) | Reduction in evaluation — compensation | Lowering a disability rating. You get advance written notice, 60 days to submit evidence, and 30 days to ask for a hearing. |
| (f) | Reduction in evaluation — pension | The same protections, applied to pension rather than compensation. |
| (g) | Reduction in evaluation — monetary allowance under 38 U.S.C. chapter 18 | Reductions to the chapter 18 allowance paid for certain children of veterans. |
| (h) | Other reductions/discontinuances | Reductions and discontinuances not covered by the subsections above. |
| (i) | Predetermination hearings | Your right to be heard before a proposed reduction becomes final. |
| (j) | Supplemental claims and higher-level review | How this section interacts with the review lanes created by the AMA. |
Got a proposed-reduction letter? The clock is already running. Under § 3.105(e) you have 60 days to submit evidence against a proposed reduction, and only 30 days to request a predetermination hearing under § 3.105(i). Ask for the hearing — if you request it in time, your payments continue at the current level while the VA decides. Don't wait for the reduction to take effect and then appeal it.
What makes an error a "CUE"
This is a high bar. It must be:
- An error of fact or law that is undebatable — reasonable people could not disagree it was wrong.
- An error that, if corrected, would have manifestly changed the outcome.
- Based on the record and law as they existed at the time of the original decision.
When you can file
There is no time limit. A decision from the 1980s can be challenged today, as long as it became final — the appeal window closed without an appeal, or it was decided on appeal. If granted, the corrected decision takes effect as of the original decision, which can mean years of retroactive back pay.
Common grounds for CUE
When a CUE does exist, it usually falls into one of a few patterns:
- A regulation in force at the time was misapplied or ignored, and that changed the result.
- The effective date contradicts dates the record plainly showed.
- A finding of fact is flatly contradicted by the documents in the file.
- A clear mathematical or rating-schedule mistake.
CUE vs. not CUE
| Could be CUE | Not CUE |
|---|---|
| A regulation in force was applied incorrectly, changing the result | You disagree with how the rater weighed the evidence |
| The effective date contradicts dates plainly in the record | New evidence has come to light since the decision (that's a Supplemental Claim) |
| A finding of fact is flatly contradicted by the documents | The law changed after the decision was made |
| A plain rating-schedule or math error | The error wouldn't have changed the outcome |
Most denials are not CUE. If the rater weighed conflicting evidence and reached a defensible call, there is no CUE — even if you'd have weighed it differently. For most situations, a supplemental claim or appeal is the better path.
How to file
There is no dedicated VA form for a CUE motion — it's written correspondence identifying the specific error, commonly submitted on VA Form 21-4138 (Statement in Support of Claim). Given the high bar and the retroactive stakes, it's the kind of claim that benefits most from a VA-accredited representative.
How the CUE check helps
Spotting a CUE means reading an old decision against the regulations and the record that existed at the time — slow, technical work. The CUE Detector does the first pass: it pulls out the rater's findings, the regulations cited, and the effective dates; flags what might be worth a closer look; and explains in plain language why each flag might rise to CUE — and, just as importantly, when it likely does not. A flag is a starting point, not a verdict: whether an error meets the CUE standard is a legal judgment the VA makes.
CUE in a Board decision
Section 3.105(a) covers decisions by a VA regional office. A decision by the Board of Veterans' Appeals is challenged for CUE by a motion filed with the Board itself, under a separate set of rules in 38 CFR 20.1400 through 20.1411. The standard is the same: an undebatable error that would have manifestly changed the outcome. And under § 3.105(a)(1)(v), once the Board has decided an issue on appeal, the regional office decision on that issue can no longer be revised under § 3.105(a); the challenge has to go after the Board decision.
Frequently asked questions
What is 38 CFR 3.105(a)?
It is the VA regulation on clear and unmistakable error. It says a final VA decision is accepted as correct on the record and law at the time, unless it contains CUE, and that a decision revised for CUE takes effect as if the corrected decision had been made on the original date.
What is the definition of clear and unmistakable error?
Under 38 CFR 3.105(a)(1)(i), CUE is a very specific and rare kind of error of fact or law that compels the conclusion, to which reasonable minds could not differ, that the result would have been manifestly different but for the error. If it is not absolutely clear a different result would have followed, it is not CUE.
Is there a time limit to file a CUE claim?
No. You can request review of a final decision for CUE at any time, including decisions made decades ago.
What is not clear and unmistakable error?
A disagreement with how the evidence was weighed, VA's failure to help you get evidence (the duty to assist), a new or corrected diagnosis made after the decision, and a later change in how a law or regulation is interpreted. 38 CFR 20.1403(d) lists examples like these.
How do I file a CUE claim?
In writing, signed by you or your representative. Give your name, VA file number, and the date of the decision; identify the issue; and state the specific error, why it was an error on the record and law at the time, and why the outcome would have been manifestly different. VA Form 21-4138 is commonly used, and the CUE Detector can help you find what to cite.
VA forms mentioned in this guide
Want free, personalized help?
A VA-accredited Veterans Service Officer (VSO) helps with your claim at no cost — filing, evidence review, and appeals. Find an accredited representative on VA.gov →
This guide is educational information about the VA claims system — it is not legal or medical advice, and it does not predict or promise any claim outcome. Regulations and procedures change; always verify current requirements at VA.gov. VA Claim Commander is a self-service documentation tool, not a VSO, law firm, or VA-accredited representative.